NXT5-Star ClassicNXT Black-and-Gold Era

Andrade "Cien" Almas vs Johnny Gargano

NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia — January 27, 2018 · Wells Fargo Center, Philadelphia, PA

▶ Plays right here in our player — official upload, verified.

The Story

Andrade Almas retained the NXT Championship, surviving a career-making challenge from Johnny Gargano in a bout that earned the first WWE-banner five-star Meltzer rating in years. It transformed Almas into a top talent and cemented Gargano as NXT's emotional heartbeat.

The match was a near-flawless blend of Almas's newfound charisma, the ruthless ringside presence of manager Zelina Vega, and Gargano's babyface fire. Gargano wrestled with the desperation of a man chasing his first singles title, stringing together a series of near-falls so convincing the Philadelphia crowd roared for a title change that never came.

Every time Gargano surged, Vega found a way to tilt the balance — a distraction, a well-timed interference — buying Almas the opening he needed to land the hammerlock DDT and retain. The heartbreak of Gargano falling just short was the point: it launched the Gargano vs Tommaso Ciampa saga that would dominate NXT for the next year and produce some of the promotion's greatest matches.

FAQ

Who won Almas vs Gargano at NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia?
Andrade "Cien" Almas retained the NXT Championship, defeating Johnny Gargano with help from Zelina Vega at ringside.
What star rating did the match get?
Dave Meltzer awarded a full 5 stars — a rare WWE-produced five-star match — and Cagematch community scores sit around 9.2/10. Wrestle Lore also rates it 5 stars.
Why does this match matter?
It made Almas a top talent, cemented Gargano as NXT's emotional heartbeat, and launched the Gargano vs Tommaso Ciampa saga that dominated NXT for the next year.